Justice Starts Here

Premier Personal Injury & Wrongful Death Attorneys

Free Consultations | Se Habla Español
Rapoport Law Offices, P.C.
312-445-9160
877-216-4213

More finger pointing regarding napping air traffic controller incident

You likely heard about a situation last week in which two airline flights, including one from Chicago, landed at Reagan National airport without the assistance of the air traffic controller who had dozed off. Fortunately both plans landed safely, but now there are rumblings within the airline industry about what should happen when a situation like this arises.

While the air traffic controller was obviously not performing his duties properly by falling asleep in the tower, some in the industry are now saying that the pilots of the two planes also acted improperly by landing at the airport even though there was not radio contact with the tower. The planes could have been diverted to another airport or at least stayed in a holding pattern while it was determined why there was no communication with the airport.

While the air traffic controller was obviously not performing his duties properly by falling asleep in the tower, some in the industry are now saying that the pilots of the two planes also acted improperly by landing at the airport even though there was not radio contact with the tower. The planes could have been diverted to another airport or at least stayed in a holding pattern while it was determined why there was no communication with the airport.

A spokeswoman for American Airlines said that their pilot's decision to land at the airport was in compliance Federal Aviation Administration guidelines for an uncontrolled airport. Indeed there are procedures for landing at an airport at which there is no air traffic controller. But a number of safety experts say that an uncontrolled airport is very different than an airport that is supposed to have 24 hour air traffic control but the tower has gone silent. In those uncontrolled airports landings are generally scheduled in advance to ensure that the runways are clear of any maintenance trucks or crossing traffic.

The FAA investigation of the incident has so far focused mostly on mistakes by the controller and whether they should continue to allow a single controller to work in the tower or if there should always be two on duty. But investigators are also now reviewing the actions of the flight crew. While pilots are generally given final authority about where to land in the case of an emergency neither plane in this case had reported being low on fuel or having any other problems on board that required an immediate landing. There are also other airports that were open and fully staffed within just 20 miles.

Source: Wall Street Journal "Decisions by Pilots to Land Criticized" Andy Paztor, March 28, 2011

3 Comments

Air traffic controllers working lonely late-night shifts are in the spotlight after federal officials suspended a controller who apparently fell asleep on the job at Ronald Reagan Washington National Airport. This really a terrible thing. Air controllers should take care of everything. Thank god all are safe.

There's nothing dangerous about landing at an airport with a sleeping controller, or without a controller. There's thousands of landings at uncontrolled airports every day! Pilots don't need controllers to land safely! Pilots know how to deconflict with other aircraft by radio.....
A pilot doesn't require a controllers permission to land, the pilot in command has the final responsibility, not the controller.

Of course we understand the respective roles and responsibilities of ATC and pilots in command of aircraft. While a sleeping controller may not be a defense to a pilot that also blows it, we’re pretty sure you would agree that regardless, controllers sleeping on the job does nothing to add to the safety net.

Leave a comment
Comment Information

Recent Jury Verdicts &
Settlements

$6.4 Million Settlement Medical Malpractice

More Verdicts & Settlements
  • National board of trial academy
  • ABPLA | American Board of Professional Liability Attorneys
  • AV preeminent | Peer rated for highest level of professional excellence 2018
  • The best lawyer in America
  • Super Lawyers
  • America's top 100 high stakes litigators
  • The national trial lawyers top 100 trial lawyers
  • Avvo Rating 10.0 Superb Top rated personal injury
  • American association for justice president's club
  • American association for justice Leaders forum
  • ACBCA American College of Board Certified Attorneys
  • B Injury Board
  • Recommended by peers for leading lawyers network the top lawyers

*AV®, AV Preeminent®, Martindale-Hubbell Distinguished and Martindale-Hubbell Notable are certification marks used under license in accordance with the Martindale-Hubbell certification procedures, standards and policies. Martindale-Hubbell® is the facilitator of a peer review rating process. Ratings reflect the anonymous opinions of members of the bar and the judiciary. Martindale-Hubbell® Peer Review Ratings™ fall into two categories — legal ability and general ethical standards.

**Board certification is not required to practice law in Illinois, and the Illinois Supreme Court does not recognize specialties in the practice of law.

What Our Clients Say

  • Just wanted to take a moment to say thank you. I know a lot of hard work, by all of you, went into the preparation of this case and we wanted you to know that it is greatly appreciated. We worried about many things during that period, but one thing we didn't worry about was our attorneys. What a fine team you make! You guys are great! Read More
  • I wanted to touch base with everyone again to express my thanks to everyone involved in the USAir 1016 case for the way the case was handled and the way you treated myself and my family. While I realize that there are other law firms that could have tried the case, I don't believe they could have matched the caring you showed us... Read More
  • How do we thank you for doing such a tremendous job with the lawsuit against Freeport Memorial Hospital?...The day that check arrived I was so nervous, in fact I was a wreck until we had it safely invested. I am not thanking you just as our attorney, but as a very good friend...Read More
  • We would like to take this opportunity to express our heartfelt thanks for the supportive service that you have given our family during the past three years. While we wish that we would not have found ourselves in a situation requiring your services, we are grateful for the sensitive way...Read More
Email Us For a Response

Have Questions? We Have Answers.

Tell us about your case and we’ll get back to you with a FREE case evaluation.

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information
disclaimer.

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.

close

Premier Personal Injury & Wrongful Death Attorneys

Call 877-216-4213 or Email Us For A Free Initial Consultation

 Rapoport Law Offices, P.C

Office Location

20 North Clark Street
Suite 3500
Chicago, IL 60602

Toll Free: 877-216-4213
Phone: 312-445-9160
Chicago Law Office Map

Contact Information

Map